A. That is a dispute between Raboh & Rava.
***
Q. When is Sumchos modeh ?
A. When there is a Torah obligation to swear we do not say - divide.
***
Q. What are the 4 things for which there is no Torah oath ?
A. Fields , servants , documents & hegdesh.
###
Q. What is R. Meirs opinion by servants ?
A. They are as movable items.
***
Q. What is the rule by the 3 oaths that are Torah obligations ?
A. They swear in order so they do not have to pay.
Now may be a good time for a gem of Torah study.
www.GemsofTorah.com